Best Eyeliner for Sensitive Eyes

Best Eyeliner for Sensitive Eyes

Since the skin on our top and lower eyelids is so delicate, we must take additional care. Avoid applying harsh chemicals if you have sensitive skin; the best eyeliners for sensitive skin should be your best cosmetics. You can use them to protect your skin while enhancing your eye makeup. That is, in our opinion, the most exciting component. Waterproof, long-lasting, and simple to apply, these eyeliners are a must-have.

List of the best eyeliner for those with sensitive eyes

Finding eyeliner that works for you if you have sensitive skin might be problematic. Consequently, we’ve created a line of products that are mild on your skin while still providing brilliant color.

NYX Mechanical Eye Pencil, Aqua Green

This eyeliner pen’s creamy texture and rich pigment cover like liquid eyeliner, giving you a defined brow and defined eyes in seconds. There’s no need to sharpen your eyeliner for a winged-out appearance. This smudge-proof eyeliner glides on easily and evenly, and it lasts all day, even in humid weather. You can achieve any eyeliner look with our Retractable Eye Pencil, from natural to dazzling.

NYX Professional Makeup has it all for eye makeup, from eyeshadow palettes to mascara and eyeliners to concealers and setting sprays. We’ve been certified as a cruelty-free brand by PETA, and we never test our products on animals. Try out all of our NYX Professional Makeup professional makeup and beauty products. Everything from eyeshadow to lipstick to foundation to blush and bronzer to brushes and more can be found in this category.

Marcelle 2-in-1 Retractable Eyeliner, Black, Hypoallergenic, and Fragrance

Eyeliner tips come in two varieties: one for crayons and the other for sponges. Waterproof and easy to smear for a smokey eye effect. A built-in sharpener is included.

Honeybee Gardens Effortless Eye Liner, Jet Set

Our Effortless Eye Liner’s long-lasting, non-abrasive formula won’t irritate the skin. It slips on smoothly and effortlessly from the moment you open the door. For a durable and faultless finish, it’s simple to apply. PETA-approved, vegan, paraben-free, cruelty-free, gluten-free, and vegan.

They are designed and manufactured in Germany. The color of departure is a deep matte black. You can also use the brow filler as an eyeshadow base. Contact lens users and anyone with sensitive eyes should avoid this product.

Physicians Formula Eye Definer Automatic Eye Pencil Ultra Black

A waterproof, intensely pigmented eyeliner pencil that stays put all day. Create a dramatic cat eye with sweeping motions or smearing. The pencil has a removable sharpener on the underside. Our eyeliner pens and pencils are dermatologist-approved and hypoallergenic. They blend well for a defined eye, powerful or subtle. Physician’s Formula has eye-enhancing cosmetics such as eyeshadow palettes, eyeliners, mascara, eyelash serums, brow gels, and eye primers.

Dermatologists suggest Physician’s Formula’s extensive array of sensitive skin products, including cosmetics and skincare. It includes mascara, lipstick, concealer, and eyeliner. Our hypoallergenic products are excellent for people with sensitive skin and eyes. The more than 150 recognized irritants found in traditional cosmetics are absent from our hypoallergenic cosmetics.

The trio of Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips

Create the most glitter with these thin, highly colored pencils. This 24-hour glitter eyeliner set defines and brightens eyes instantly for a long-lasting look. Our eyeliner pens and pencils are dermatologist-approved and hypoallergenic. They blend well for a defined eye, powerful or subtle. Physician’s Formula has eye-enhancing cosmetics such as eyeshadow palettes, eyeliners, mascara, eyelash serums, brow gels, and eye primers.

Dermatologists suggest Physician’s Formula’s extensive array of sensitive skin products, including cosmetics and skincare. It includes mascara, lipstick, concealer, and eyeliner. Our hypoallergenic products are excellent for people with sensitive skin and eyes. Healthy Beauty Products: Besides being hypoallergenic, our products are devoid of the over 150 recognized carcinogens in traditional personal care products.

Neutrogena Precision Liquid Eyeliner with Honey & Coconut

Neutrogena Precision Liquid Eyeliner in Jet Black is a high-pigment, water-resistant eyeliner that provides well-defined lash lines that won’t break or melt. Eyeliner applies smoothly and fast, allowing you to create bold, clean, and precise lines effortlessly. The smudge-proof eyeliner dries quickly and lasts long so that it won’t fade or flake. With this hypoallergenic black eye makeup, you can expect a smooth application and smudge-free lines. The applicator on liquid eyeliner does not tear and makes an even line in one stroke, making it simple to use.

Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner, Midnight Gray – 0.04 Ounce

We’ve created an eyeliner that won’t fade or smear on your eyes’ delicate skin to enhance your natural eye color. Children’s natural nutrients: natural ingredients include cedarwood, calming jojoba, meadowfoam seed, and mango oil, all 99.9% natural.

Quick and easy to use: even if you wear contact lenses or have sensitive eyes, swipe on the upper or lower lash line for a short burst of color to emphasize and beautifully define your eyes. An eyeliner pencil for drawing the eyes precisely. Enhance blue, green, brown, or hazel eyes with soft black, midnight gray, or warm brown eyeliner.

Makeup without artificial ingredients: it was ophthalmologist-tested and is free of parabens, phthalates, SLS, petroleum, talc, synthetic fragrances, and silicones, all common ingredients in other eye pencils. Animals were never used in the testing process.

Physicians Formula Ultra-Fine Liquid Eyeliner Deep Brown

This multi-tasking formula looks fantastic as a LIQUID eyeliner and enhances the look of eyelashes at the base of the lashes. The eyelashes are also nourished and conditioned by it. Physician’s Formula offers a variety of eye-enhancing products, ranging from eyeshadow palettes and eyeliners to mascaras and eyelash serums and brow gels, and eye primers. Our eyeliner pens and pencils are hypoallergenic, cruelty-free, hypoallergenic, dermatologist-approved, and safe for contact lens wearers. They apply smoothly for a defined eye, whether bold or subtle.

Physician’s Formula’s comprehensive collection of goods for sensitive skin, which includes a wide selection of makeup and skincare items, is recommended by dermatologists. Everything from mascara and lipstick to concealer and eyeliner is included. Because our products are hypoallergenic, they are suitable for persons with sensitive skin and eyes. Healthy Beauty Products: Our products are hypoallergenic, safe for sensitive skin and eyes, and free of the over 150 known hazardous ingredients found in other personal care products.

Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner Pencil

This eyeshadow pencil has an embedded sharpener and a contoured smudger to help you create a delicate, blended smoky eye look. The light diffusers in the eyeliner pencil help brighten the eyes’ whites. Because of the inclusion of healthy olive oil and rainforest shea butter in the composition applies quickly and remains set all day without fading or smearing.

As a result, the eye makeup recipe is safe and gentle for individuals who wear contact lenses or have sensitive eyes. With this eyeliner, you can use any Neutrogena Mascara or remove it with Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover.

L’Oreal Paris Makeup Infallible Never Fail Original

Infallible eyeliner with a built-in sharpener that won’t smudge for up to 16 hours has been developed to slide smoothly and stay put. This creamy eye pencil provides long-lasting, fade-proof color. Use the pencil’s built-in sharpener to fine-tune the point to get a range of eye expressions. Continue gliding to build traditional or dramatic eye designs that may be tailored to any mood or circumstance.

Voluminous mascaras, smudge-proof eyeliner, defined brows, and eye shadow palettes for every eye color are all available to help you create the ultimate eye makeup look. Foundations, concealers, highlighters, brow pencils, eyeshadow palettes, lipsticks, and more are available from l’oreal Paris to help you get the look you want.

Serving suggestions: the formula for voluminous original volume building mascara is one-of-a-kind, resulting in lashes that are up to five times thicker than they are naturally.

Almay Eyeliner Pencil, Hypoallergenic, Cruelty-Free

 An eyeliner pencil that glides smoothly across your lids without catching or dragging. To keep it in good shape, the tip of this mechanical pencil eyeliner may be dialed up and down. There’s even a built-in sharpener. The solution, which comes in six rich hues, has been fortified with vitamin E. All products are hypoallergenic, ophthalmologist-tested, scent-free, and cruelty-free.

Fifth & Skin Better’n Ur Eyes Eyeliner Pencil


Amazon’s best-seller natural eyeliner with a free pencil sharpener! – ingredients are organic and natural. Enhance and clarify the shape and color of your eyes for a more appealing appearance. There should be no squeezing or straining of the delicate eye area. You won’t have to wipe away your tears because it’s hypoallergenic and long-lasting. This might be beneficial to eyes that are more susceptible to irritants. It is created with non-toxic components to limit the danger of irritation. It lasts for the entire day.

Let go of the anxiety you’re experiencing because of your cosmetics. This natural eyeliner contains healing jojoba and castor oils. Castor oil promotes the growth of eyelashes. This product is made entirely of natural ingredients and is gluten-free, vegetarian, and cruelty-free. It is also devoid of lead, petroleum, parabens, and scent. As this example shows, long-lasting eyeliner pencils are water-resistant (not waterproof). If you need to carry this in your purse or on your travels, you can always touch up on the fly. Without any risk made in the united states and guaranteed by a money-back guarantee. It’s made in the united states of America; please let me know what you’re looking forward to! Place your purchase right now.

Best Eyeliner For Sensitive Eyes (Buying Guide)


Choosing an eyeshadow color that complements your eye color is the most effective way to achieve your desired look. To begin, choose an eyeliner color that you enjoy. Alternatively, you might be looking for a color you can wear all day.


Eyeliners come in a variety of colors and styles. With liquid eyeliner, you can draw tiny, precise lines. On the other hand, a Felt-tip eyeliner can create thicker but softer lines. Pencil eyeliner can make thin, thick, sharp, or smooth lines depending on the pencil. As a result, it’s critical to choose eyeliner that will assist you in achieving your objectives.


If you use waterproof eyeliners, you won’t worry about spreading or flaking. Anyone who lives in a dry or humid climate will appreciate these eyeliners. These are also an excellent choice for those who wear contact lenses or suffer from watery eyes.

Return Policy

You may occasionally purchase a product only to discover that it does not work for you after using it. Depending on the shop, you may be allowed to return an item whether or not you’ve used it. It’s tough to produce things that have been opened or used. Before making a purchase, think about the return policy.

Hand Steadiness

To begin, ensure that you have steady hands to select the ideal eyeliner. A pencil eyeliner may be more convenient if you have shaky hands or are new to eyeliner. For those who have perfected the art of eyeliner application and have steady hands, liquid eyeliners are the best alternative. They’re the easiest to utilize.

Eyeliner Type

The eyeliner comes in two primary forms: traditional pencil and liquid, depending on your preferences. Taking a deeper look at the many types:

Pencil Eyeliner

Eyeliner is traditionally applied with a pencil. For a long time, it has been in use. You can choose between a traditional pencil and a mechanical pencil that sharpens itself. Pencils are the best option if you’re seeking an eyeliner that doesn’t include a lot of chemicals. As a result, they’re frequently a better option for people who have sensitive eyelids. Furthermore, they tend to maintain their fitness for a longer time. Sharpening them, on the other hand, can be a pain. They can also be crumbled easily.

Liquid Eyeliner

Liquid liners are bolder, more colorful, and often come in a broader choice of colors than eye pencils. Some liquid eyeliners include serums to improve the health and appearance of your eyes. These pencils eliminate the need to sharpen pencil liners, which can be messy.

As a result, persons with sensitive skin eyes are more prone to be irritated by them. Because they often have a more significant concentration of allergens, this is the case. You’ll also have to pay greater attention to keeping liquid eyeliner fresh because it degrades quickly.

Eyeliner Ingredients

Many chemicals are used to achieve the pigmentation and longevity of eyeliner. Liquid eyeliner may contain additional chemicals to maintain its gel-like consistency. Using just natural or synthetic eyeliners is a good idea. If you have sensitive eyes, read the ingredient list on the eyeliner carefully. Avoid anything that contains carbon black or similar possibly dangerous material.

Staying Power

Eyeliners have different levels of staying power. Your eyeliner’s formula decides how long it will remain on your eyes. Look for a recipe with an 8-12 hour wear time if you want your makeup to last all day. If you have to use makeup remover to get the eyeliner off at the end, it’s likely to last all day.

Skin Tone

Take your skin tone into consideration when choosing eyeliner. Using the wrong eyeliner shade might bring out the worst features of your natural skin. You should avoid actual black liquid eyeliner if you have a fair skin tone. If you apply black eyeliner, your skin will appear harsh. Choose a brown powder or gel eyeliner for a more natural appearance.

On the other side, black eyeliner looks fantastic on persons with medium to dark skin tones. This is an excellent option if you want your eyes to be the center of attention.

Eyeliner Finish

These days, matte eyeliners are the norm. Some, on the other hand, have a glossy or shimmering finish. A matte finish is a way to go for those looking for something more subtle. As a result, your makeup won’t be overpowering. A bright glossy finish may be the answer to adding a flash of color.

Sensitive Eyes Makeup Tips

Lining The Inner Eye Is Harmful

The inner-eye lining must be done with utmost caution if you have sensitive eyes. Line the outer lash line with a pencil or a liner.

Always wash off makeup before bed.

Many women will agree that taking off their makeup is a difficult chore. After a long day, you don’t want to take off your makeup.

Moderate Use Of Eye Cream

Apply eye cream on the outer and inner corners of your eyes gently.

Some Ingredients Should Be Avoided

Those with sensitive eyes or skin should avoid eyeliners that include specific ingredients. Allergic reactions can be produced by any of the common allergens listed below.


Alcohol is a preservative in many cosmetics since it is an excellent way to keep makeup fresh. It also kills bacteria and tightens pores, which are two extra advantages. It is inappropriate for persons with sensitive skin because it might cause irritation or dryness in the eyes.


In recent years, the use of various harmful chemical compounds in makeup, such as parabens, sulfates, BHAs, and others, has gotten much attention. Due to recent results, several companies are already removing these compounds from their products. As a result, several cosmetics companies are eliminating these substances from their products. It hasn’t been proven. However, persons with sensitive skin should avoid cosmetics that include perfumes for the time being.


Chemicals are used to improve the fragrance of items, yet these chemicals are known to cause considerable skin damage. Many makeup fans have claimed that the odor is a possible cause of skin hypersensitivity. Allergy sufferers should watch this common allergen and stay away from it. The majority of high-quality, moderately cost cosmetics manufacturers offer fragrance-free solutions.


Is there any eyeliner that won’t hurt my sensitive eyes?

If you’re going to tightline or apply eyeliner along your waterline, you’ll need an eyeliner that’s both non-irritating and ultrafine. The liner for BAREMINERALS is one of the two. It is devoid of significant allergies and is vegan, cruelty-free, and mineral pigment-based.

Why are my eyes irritated by eyeliner?

It generates a burning feeling. Chemicals that irritate. According to the Study, any debris from the air or cosmetics might scratch and burn the eyes. Irritating preservatives in eyeliner and mascara, according to Movsisyan, are the greatest offenders when it comes to cosmetics since they’re so close to your eyes.

How should you apply eyeliner?

The eyeliner application is controlled by a series of guidelines. Pushing the eyes outwards is the most common of them. Avoid this technique if you don’t want your eyelid line to be changed when you release it. Keep your eyes closed and prevent squinting during the operation. When you’re ready, draw a line between the level of your lashes and the junction of your eyelids. After that, you should have confidence in your ability. Instead of a large mirror, use a smaller mirror that is somewhat lower than the height of your head. You’ll be able to see your eyes in a whole other way.

What is the best way to remove eyeliner?

Here are a few suggestions to assist you in saving time by reducing the number of times you have to retouch your work. First, apply a primer. Because the eyelid won’t grow oily, you’ll notice a distinct improvement in the hold. If you like liquid or gel pens and inks, use a pencil as a base. As a result of doing this maneuver, your grip will improve. For an added boost of confidence, use black eyeshadow over your eyeliner.

How to remove water-resistant eyeliner?

To complete this assignment, select your teammates. Choose an oil-based makeup remover if you need to remove your makeup. Apply it with a cotton pad. After 20 seconds of application, massage your face. Use a light soap to clean your face.


Your eyeliners may be unsafe if they don’t match your skin tone. Using cosmetics on your eyes that aren’t vegan-friendly or made for delicate skin can be dangerous. The accompanying list contains every single one of the best eyeliners for sensitive eyes on our list.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *